Monday, January 11, 2016

Chicano Park and Immigrant Detention Centers

Destiny Lopez
Research Statement
Topic #1
Chicano Park is located in Barrio Logan, an area of San Diego that has historically been home to much of the city’s Mexican-American population. The park was established after a non-violent demonstration by Barrio Logan residents, and today it is a symbol of San Diego’s Chicano community. The park was established after the historical Mexican-American barrio came under the threat of being rezoned into an industrial area. Residents fought for Chicano Park as a way to resist the destruction of their community and reclaim the area (which was to be turned into a parking lot) for Chicanos. I am interested in the history of Chicano Park in the broader context of Chicano history. How did the establishment of Chicano Park align with the goals of the Chicano Movement? In particular, what is the connection between the creation of Chicano Park and the notion of “Azltan” – that is, the push to reclaim United States land that formerly belonged to Mexico?   How does the Chicano Movement of the 1970s trace back to the Mexican-American War and subsequent loss of land, and how does that relate to the history of Chicano Park?
Current sources:
This Land Was Mexican Once: Histories of Resistance from Northern California, Linda Heidenreich
Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza, Gloria Anzaldua
Wish list of sources:
·         San Diego history during Chicano movement and after Mexican-American War
·         Barrio Logan history
·         Chicano Park history
·         Chicano movement and the notion of Aztlan


Topic #2
Immigration detention centers have received attention in recent years due with the rise of Central American refugees fleeing violence.  I am interested in the experience of immigrants who have been detained throughout different points in American history. Which immigrants faced detention upon arrival in the United States, and which immigrants did not? How did the race, country of origin, and class background of different immigrant groups impact whether they were detained and the conditions in which they were detained? What were some of the historic contexts that dictated how different waves of immigrants were treated upon arrival?
Angel Island: Immigrant Gateway to American, Erika Lee and Judy Yung
A Nation of Immigrants, Susan F. Martin
American Passage: A History of Ellis Island, Vincent J Cannato
Wish list of sources:
·         The history of immigrant detention centers
·         History of immigration in the United States, with emphasis on how different waves of immigrants had different experiences
·         How the race, country of origin, and class backgrounds of immigrants inform their experience


5 comments:

  1. With regards to your first topic, I really like how your are using a very specific historical question to illustrate something about the broader Chicano movement. In terms of understanding the connection between Chicano Park and Azltan, you might consider reading personal statements (e.g. diary entries), if available. What was the political and socio-economic context in which residents founded Chicano Park?

    The second topic is fascinating, especially as it pertains to contemporary events. You might consider religion in addition to race, class and origin. This is actually quite a broad topic and you might consider doing a very methodological survey throughout U.S. history and then narrowing in on the experiences of two or three groups (a comparative study of sorts). You might also consider the relationship between likelihood of detention and the (changing) U.S. enemy number one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Destiny,
    I enjoyed the way in which you were able to relate the Chicano Park anecdote to a broader topic - the Chicano movement and Azlatan. I can already see that story as the opening of a great paper about the Chicano movement! The only recommendation I have is to perhaps refine exactly what you are seeking to prove about the movement itself (this will definitely reveal itself over time so don’t sweat it!). I honestly think you have a great start, and I look forward to seeing where this goes! Your second topic is very current and could be exciting to pursue in light of the debates about immigration going on at this very moment. It is broad at the moment, so I think picking a few specific groups that were detained (or not) throughout history could help create a really cohesive paper.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Destiny,

    To write about Chicano Park as a synecdoche of the Chicano movement as a whole means that you may need to spend most of your paper defining what the Chicano Movement was/is and what it means to its adherents. Without a specific time-frame (the 1960/70's?) or region of the country (Northern California?), it may be very difficult to accurately define the movement. Your last question expands the scope of your paper by 100 years and by itself would probably be a worthwhile topic, as would be a paper covering the Aztlan campaign. Concentrating on Chicano Park will help keep the paper focused.

    The second topic is immediately relevant and interesting. I would echo Chiara's suggested of narrowing the scope of your research to perhaps the experience of a couple different groups? Finding a firm place in time and space will ground the essay.

    I'd be very interested to read either!
    -Dan Ruprecht

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really like your first topic! It would be really interesting to see whether the organizers of the fight to save the park initially saw what they were doing as part of a broader struggle, or if that consciousness developed over time. Was there a particular leader who helped elevate the struggle to that broader context? Basically, I'm wondering if there was a pattern like that of the Montgomery bus boycott where initially the struggle was seen as a more isolated, local matter until MLK was able to use oratory to tie their struggle into a larger historical and religious context.

    I agree with others that you'll have to narrow the second topic down a lot, but it would definitely make an interesting essay. Maybe focus on a group that has had multiple waves of immigration during very different historical eras to try to isolate the extent to which current events versus general xenophobia is important?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Destiny! I love both your topics- so fascinating and both things I don't know much about. Looking at your list of sources and the wish list, I believe you would have greater success with your second topic. I personally find your second topic a bit more interesting because your research could really shed light on the current policies and issues surrounding current immigration and the political and personal tensions that result. That being said, some of the questions you are in your first topic are really intriguing, especially the potential relationship between Chicano Park and reclaiming former parts of Mexico. I think you could have great success with either topic! I look forward to reading your paper :)

    ReplyDelete