Monday, January 11, 2016

Zoot Suit Manhood / State Involvement in Lynching

Topic 1: Zoot Suit Manhood
Research Statement:
In the summer of 1943, a group of American sailors stationed near Los Angeles descended upon the Carmen Theater looking for blood. They began to bludgeon and beat a group of 12-13 year old boys and the adults who tried to protect them, tearing off the boys clothes to light a bonfire. Police stood by to watch as the sailors tore off the boys' clothes to light a bonfire. The only apparent crime: the boys were Mexican American "zooters," young men with a penchant for extravagant and easily-recognizable zoot suits. Over the course of the next few weeks, the attacks would spread across the nation as angry U.S. servicemen assaulted young Mexican Americans in Chicago, New York City, and Philadelphia. Conventional narratives of the Zoot Suit Riot -- or the "Zoot Suit War," to take the term popular in newspapers of the day -- stress that the servicemen felt that the Mexican Americans' clothing, at a time when Americans were being asked to ration textiles, was overtly unpatriotic or subversive. Thus the focus of most attacks was to burn and often urinate on the zoot suits rather than abuse the men wearing them.
I want to explore, however, how the violence could have emerged from varying definitions of American Manhood, to find out if the pachuco arrogance and flamboyance could have sparked as much violence. If one sees the attacks as a form of public humiliation against the Mexican American youths, then the violence can instead be seen as punishment for insufficient manhood in the eyes of servicemen who idealized austerity and obedience. This means I'll need to source explore the origins of pachuco culture on the west coast and how it spread throughout the nation, and compare that culture with what white servicemen may have expected or desired in American men.
Current sources:
  • Pagan, E.O., "Los Angeles Geopolitics and the Zoot Suit Riots, 1943" Social Science History vol 24, num 1, (Spring 2000) 223-256.
  • Peiss, Kathy Lee, Zoot Suit: The Enigmatic Career of an Extreme Style, (2011).
  • "Zoot Suit Riots" PBS videorecording, (2007). at the media/microtext desk
Wishlist:
  • Letters from soldiers/interviews about what it means to be an American or a man in America
  • Police transcripts during the riot explaining why only Mexican-Americans were imprisoned
  • Diary/letters from pachucos about how they fit -- or didn't -- into their dual cultures
  • Demographic information on the U.S. army--how many were Mexican American? Did white soldiers know Mexican soldiers.

Topic 2: State Involvement in Lynching
Research Statement:
The typical narrative of a lynching in the south is simple: a crowd of whites, angry at a committed or perceived crime, declares a black member or family of their community guilty. They proceed to kidnap and often beat the victim before publicly hanging them in a spectacle often attended by the an entire town, in which it was not rare for people to claim body parts as souvenirs or write about the murder as a celebration. Where, I ask, are law enforcement officials involved in this process? Why were mobs allows to take the law into their own hands with no repercussion, ignoring any kind of pretense of trial-by-jury or legal procedure whatsoever? Were government officials everywhere complicit in this kind of repeated structural violence, or did some attempt to stop the lynchings?
Current Sources:
  • Thurston, Robert W., Lynching: American Mob Murder in Global Perspective, (2011).
  • Rushdy, Ashraf H.A., American Lynching, (2012).
  • Kato, Daniel, Liberalizing Lynching (2016).
Wish List:
  • Statements from white mobs arguing the efficacy and moral justification of lynching
  • Any law enforcement documents about the murders available
  • Newspapers supporting and attacking mob violence


5 comments:

  1. Your topics seem interesting. I also like your sources.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Dan, I really like your topic ideas and I can tell you have already spent quite a little bit of time thinking about how race, manhood and other factors may be at work within Pachuco culture for your first topic. It sounds like you are pretty fired up about that particular topic! If you decide to go with that one I definitely agree you focusing on manhood/conception of masculinity during WWII a period that was all about American patriotism and loyalty would be particularly fruitful. You could also consider how media/the government represented white soldiers vs. 'others,' by looking at ads and posters from the era depicting men. If you end up going with the other topic I would make sure you include the African American voice as much as you possibly can. Also what time period of lynching are you talking about?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dan, I love both of these. The first is super specific which I think makes it ideal - super narrow event/style to examine that might allow you to make extrapolations or conclusions about larger social patterns, which is cool and a manageable approach. I specifically recall reading a piece about zoot suit culture in a history class last spring so I will email the professor and find out what it was! I think that using clothing as a way to examine gender expression is especially great because it's so tangible - there are photographs! I think it's a super strong topic. The second topic also has a lot of potential - it is a horrifying topic but one that bears considering. Perhaps one dimension to consider is anti-lynching bills that never made became laws because of their failure to pass both houses (I think in the 1930s) - an unbelievable reality that Congress apologized for only in 2005. Both of these topics are incredibly important and interesting - looking forward to seeing your progress on whichever you choose.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Dan -- it definitely looks like you've put a lot of thought and effort into the first topic, so I think that should say something about which topic you should choose. I also think your ability to write the topic you want will depend a lot on the sources you find and what they say--but even if you don't answer your specific question I think you can definitely discover something really interesting.

    In terms of your sources, I would definitely think more about expanding to images--so are these zoot suits being photographed in the media? The Hoover pamphlet/poster collection might be the way to start!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with what the other posters said -- both of your topics seem important and interesting. After even reading your first topic proposal, I was so curious that I went down a googling hole to learn more about your topic. I love the intersectionality that you work in here in terms of how racism and notions of masculinity intersect. I think that could lead to a very interesting paper. The second topic is heavy but also important. I would be interested to see if/how law enforcement in different states handled lynching differently. As Maeve said, I look forward to reading more about whichever proposal you decide on.

    ReplyDelete